Shorts Generator vs InVideo AI: Complete Comparison (2025)

Choosing the right AI video tool can make or break your content creation workflow. This guide compares Shorts Generator and InVideo AI across every dimension that matters: pricing, features, output quality, and ideal use cases.

TL;DR

Shorts Generator is better for creating original faceless content with AI-generated images, while InVideo AI is better for assembling videos from stock footage with templates. Shorts Generator costs $50/month for 30 videos; InVideo starts at $25/month with more videos but relies on stock clips. Choose Shorts Generator for unique visuals; choose InVideo for faster production with stock assets.

Quick Comparison Table

| Feature | Shorts Generator | InVideo AI | |---------|------------------|------------| | Starting Price | $50/month | $25/month | | Videos/Month | 30 (Pro), 75 (Elite) | 60+ | | Visual Style | AI-generated images | Stock footage | | AI Voices | 50+ | 100+ | | Caption Fonts | 200+ | 50+ | | Video Length | Up to 4 minutes | Up to 15 minutes | | Best For | Faceless channels, unique content | Stock-based videos, templates |

Feature Breakdown

Visual Content: AI vs Stock

This is the fundamental difference between the two platforms.

Shorts Generator creates unique AI-generated images for each scene in your video. When you input a script about "5 habits of millionaires," the AI generates custom visuals of wealth concepts, productivity scenes, and success imagery—none of which exist anywhere else on the internet.

InVideo AI pulls from stock footage libraries. You'll get professionally shot clips, but the same footage may appear in thousands of other videos. If you've ever watched a faceless YouTube video and recognized a clip from somewhere else, that's the stock footage problem.

Winner: Shorts Generator for uniqueness; InVideo for realistic footage

Voice Options

Shorts Generator offers 50+ AI voices across different accents, genders, and speaking styles. The focus is on natural-sounding narration voices optimized for short-form content.

InVideo AI provides 100+ voice options with more variety, including character voices and multiple languages.

Winner: InVideo AI for variety; tie for quality

Caption Customization

Shorts Generator leads here with 200+ caption fonts and extensive customization options. For short-form content where on-screen text is crucial for engagement, this matters significantly.

InVideo AI offers fewer font options (50+) but includes more template-based text animations and effects.

Winner: Shorts Generator for Shorts/Reels/TikTok style captions

Pricing Comparison

Shorts Generator:

• Pro: $50/month for 30 videos
• Elite: $100/month for 75 videos
• Cost per video: $1.33-$1.67

InVideo AI:

• Plus: $25/month for 50+ videos
• Max: $60/month for unlimited
• Cost per video: $0.50 or less

Winner: InVideo AI for raw cost efficiency

Output Quality

Both platforms export in 1080p. The quality difference comes down to visual style:

• Shorts Generator: Consistent AI art style, unique visuals, modern aesthetic
• InVideo AI: Professional stock footage, varied styles, realistic look

Winner: Depends on your content style preference

When to Choose Shorts Generator

Choose Shorts Generator if you:

1. Want unique visuals — Your videos won't look like everyone else's stock footage compilations
2. Are building a faceless YouTube channel — Differentiated content performs better long-term
3. Need more caption customization — 200+ fonts for that perfect TikTok/Reels aesthetic
4. Prioritize visual uniqueness over volume — Quality over quantity approach
5. Create content in competitive niches — Standing out matters more when competition is fierce

Ideal Shorts Generator Use Cases

• Motivational/self-improvement Shorts
• Finance explainers
• History and mystery content
• Educational content
• Reddit story narrations
• Scary story/creepypasta channels

When to Choose InVideo AI

Choose InVideo AI if you:

1. Need high video volume — More videos per dollar spent
2. Prefer realistic footage — Stock clips look more "professional" for some niches
3. Want more voice options — 100+ voices including multiple languages
4. Create template-based content — Their template library is extensive
5. Are comfortable with stock clips appearing in other videos — This matters less for some content types

Ideal InVideo AI Use Cases

• Product review compilations
• News recap channels
• Travel content
• Cooking/recipe videos
• Corporate explainers
• Multi-language content

Real-World Workflow Comparison

Shorts Generator Workflow

1. Enter topic: "Why most people stay broke"
2. AI generates or you paste a script
3. Select AI voice (takes 30 seconds)
4. AI generates unique images for each scene
5. Customize captions from 200+ fonts
6. Export 1080p video

Total time: 8-12 minutes

InVideo AI Workflow

1. Enter prompt describing your video
2. AI creates script and matches stock footage
3. Select voice from 100+ options
4. Review and swap any stock clips you don't like
5. Add text animations from templates
6. Export video

Total time: 10-15 minutes

The Uniqueness Factor

Here's why visual uniqueness matters more than you might think:

For YouTube Shorts/TikTok/Reels:

• Viewers scroll through hundreds of videos daily
• Recognizable stock footage triggers "I've seen this" fatigue
• Unique visuals increase watch time and completion rates
• The algorithm favors videos that keep viewers engaged

Long-term channel building:

• AI-generated visuals become part of your channel's identity
• Harder for copycats to replicate your exact style
• More defensible content moat over time

This is why channels focused on long-term growth often prefer AI-generated visuals over stock footage.

Pricing Value Analysis

Let's compare what you actually get:

$50/month Budget

With Shorts Generator (Pro):

• 30 videos with unique AI visuals
• 200+ caption fonts
• Ideal for 1 video/day on one platform

With InVideo AI (Plus + extra):

• 50+ videos with stock footage
• Template-based editing
• Ideal for 1-2 videos/day on one platform

$100/month Budget

With Shorts Generator (Elite):

• 75 videos with unique AI visuals
• Enough for 2-3 videos/day
• Great for multi-platform posting

With InVideo AI (Max):

• Unlimited videos
• Maximum volume output
• Best for high-volume operations

Making Your Decision

Choose Shorts Generator if:

• [ ] You value unique, non-stock visuals
• [ ] You're building a brand around your content
• [ ] Caption customization is important
• [ ] You create 1-2 videos per day max
• [ ] You're in competitive faceless niches

Choose InVideo AI if:

• [ ] Volume is your primary concern
• [ ] You prefer realistic stock footage
• [ ] You need 100+ voice options
• [ ] You create template-based content
• [ ] Budget is your top constraint

Conclusion

Both tools serve different needs:

Shorts Generator is the better choice for creators who want their content to stand out with unique AI-generated visuals. The 200+ caption fonts and focus on short-form optimization make it ideal for TikTok, YouTube Shorts, and Instagram Reels creators building faceless channels.

InVideo AI is the better choice for creators who prioritize volume and prefer professional stock footage. The lower cost per video and larger voice library make it suitable for high-output operations.

For most faceless YouTube channel creators focused on long-term growth, we recommend Shorts Generator for the visual differentiation advantage.

---

Ready to try Shorts Generator? Start creating unique AI videos

Not sure what to create? Use our free Shorts Ideas Generator